End of the day guys all Anthony (I see 'all' but its a massive effort), is download the original rule book, download the LRB edition highlight up what he didn't like, make a master document which eradicated all of the rules that simply were not working or were unbalanced in his (and now the communities) opinion, then modified the rulebook with house rules.......which has made it his own. His just been kind enough to share it with people.
To be quite frank......if I was Anthony and someone was b*tching about it I would probably just say "dont use it then" its mine and not made to superseed the GW edition or claim to be the official document.
Personally I like and dislike things from all three books. Iv printed all 3, read through and compared them all and modified it to suit. For example (off the top of my head), the original and CE has catching fire. I like that. Thats staying. But LRB and CE doesnt have the handflamer template or heavy flamer. In my opinion a tiny hand flamer gun, a flamer and a heavy flamer will logically have a smaller to larger spread.......iv kept that in our rules as per the original. Like I acknowledge why its been written out because it makes the game simpler but is it really that hard to have 2 more templates? Not in my opinion. Im sure others will agree/disagree with me. But the end of the day im not publishing my version of the rule book because its my rulebook. Not that im selfish at all, if someone wanted it they could have it, but in honesty im far too lazy to be defending it.
The only way that the CE comments will be constructive is by someone listing out ALL of the things that you dont like. For each item you should have a different feed whereby people vote and demonstrate their likes/dislikes for it. ie.
1. Hunter Rifle omitted because.....
2. Omit High Impact injury rules because.......
3. Omit Auto Slugger because.....
Plus there will always be discussions about House Weapon Lists and the modifications to Skills. Seriously just print off both rule lists and compare, make a house call on it. Its just Anthonys opinion within the CE. As with anyone I agree with some of the changes but disagree with some of the others. (especially when the GW figures dont match the new weapon lists) etc
You get my point. Yakromunda should really set up a specific forum feed for the CE actually because its obviously integrated iteslf within the global community. It deserves to be recognised. I would air a word of caution for any mods that are suggested and made as a consequence though. I dont think any of us want it drifting too far away from the original rule set, id keep as much the same as possible but correct it where its flawed through the voting of the community. Which again..............Anothony really doesnt have to do. The lads a saint for publishing his hard graft really. For those criticising it to the heavens.........lets have a look at your rule book.............
To be quite frank......if I was Anthony and someone was b*tching about it I would probably just say "dont use it then" its mine and not made to superseed the GW edition or claim to be the official document.
Personally I like and dislike things from all three books. Iv printed all 3, read through and compared them all and modified it to suit. For example (off the top of my head), the original and CE has catching fire. I like that. Thats staying. But LRB and CE doesnt have the handflamer template or heavy flamer. In my opinion a tiny hand flamer gun, a flamer and a heavy flamer will logically have a smaller to larger spread.......iv kept that in our rules as per the original. Like I acknowledge why its been written out because it makes the game simpler but is it really that hard to have 2 more templates? Not in my opinion. Im sure others will agree/disagree with me. But the end of the day im not publishing my version of the rule book because its my rulebook. Not that im selfish at all, if someone wanted it they could have it, but in honesty im far too lazy to be defending it.
The only way that the CE comments will be constructive is by someone listing out ALL of the things that you dont like. For each item you should have a different feed whereby people vote and demonstrate their likes/dislikes for it. ie.
1. Hunter Rifle omitted because.....
2. Omit High Impact injury rules because.......
3. Omit Auto Slugger because.....
Plus there will always be discussions about House Weapon Lists and the modifications to Skills. Seriously just print off both rule lists and compare, make a house call on it. Its just Anthonys opinion within the CE. As with anyone I agree with some of the changes but disagree with some of the others. (especially when the GW figures dont match the new weapon lists) etc
You get my point. Yakromunda should really set up a specific forum feed for the CE actually because its obviously integrated iteslf within the global community. It deserves to be recognised. I would air a word of caution for any mods that are suggested and made as a consequence though. I dont think any of us want it drifting too far away from the original rule set, id keep as much the same as possible but correct it where its flawed through the voting of the community. Which again..............Anothony really doesnt have to do. The lads a saint for publishing his hard graft really. For those criticising it to the heavens.........lets have a look at your rule book.............
