Hits meaning actual hits?

spafe

Executive Officer in charge of Hats
Staff member
Necromunda Custodian
Yak Comp 2nd Place
Tribe Council
Feb 8, 2013
11,203
16,123
283
Tilehurst, U.k.
Sparked by another convo I am now thinking, how do we interpret hits in the fluff? I always read it as a hit meant you're hit, then roll to wound is to see if its hit anything vital. That's kinda how its written in the rules and at least how myself and people I've played with have always refered to it.

I'm now thinking more in terms of, a bullet is pretty darn lethal to average joe human. esp when you're playing with things like boltgun rounds and plasma shots. Therefore is it more accurate to think in terms of a 'hit' result actually being a suppression successful, then the 'wound' roll as a have your shots hit the target and done something meaningful. In that way it happily explains why a machine gun even only has a 50/50 chance to 'wound' a human even though you've RAW hit him successfully.

Its more of a terminology thing rather than rules, but thought it might be interesting to see how others view it (and it also might indirectly relate to influencing rules on overwatching pinning, although that's very much not the intent of this thread it might shed light into reasoning)
 
I always thought of pinning as the psychological effect - no harm done, but it's due to the fighter hitting the dirt at the last moment in a bit of a panic and staying there for the duration of this fire burst (and then some, for good measure, unless an ally routes him/her back up). Not as graceful as a Dodge or other Special Save. Armor Saves still result in pinning, that means for me that grazing hits have the same effect.

That's almost contrary to the rulebook wording, where it's generally the force of the impact that's blowing the fighter off feet, and Toughness is used to prevent a wound. Toughness can be considered as the general ability to avoid harm and how close it can get and still be considered a "graze", though. The rulebook wording can also be just the result of the Pinning description put before Wounding.

I'm agreed on general lethality of lethal force weapons. :) Necromunda gangers might be tougher than our imaginary average Joe but, as you mentioned, weapons also seem to be scarier. Add a fistful of Hollywoodesqueness to the mix and we should be able to imagine whatever we need.

EDIT: Lethality aside, as originally mentioned - stopping power is an entirely separate property of the shot. I don't have the math, but it's not the amount of force, but it's concentration coupled with body fragility that is lethal. Death is also seldom instant (that's actually pictured in Necromunda).
 
Last edited:
I've always read it as
  • to hit is to literally hit the target
  • wounding determines if it hits anything vital, a flesh wound is wether the target can power on through that, albeit with a disadvantage
  • pinning is suppression - due to "counting your lucky stars" that you survived an on-target shot or being winded by the hit, especially if wearing armour
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat
Not sure I have a definitive response to this as I consider it a combination of both being forced into cover by suppressive fire and being hit/winged by a bullet that glances off your weapon, back pack or luck tobacco tin..

This is how I see it, too. You hit/would've hit your target, but due to either luck or quick reaction, there is no damage caused. The target throws himself to the ground, bullet glances off something made of metal, or hit the book he was saving to read during downtime. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat
I would still see it as a hit being in the general vicinity of the intended target, thus representing you reacting to being shot at. with the wounding roll representing hitting the target enough to injure them. this is supported by the lascannon and plasma weapons rolling a 1. if your physically hit by either, you would be wounded, with the roll of a 1 representing it just not hitting you.

this is why i see the hit roll as around the target with wounding representing actually hitting them and causing damage.
 
Hmmm, I never considered a hit to be an actual hit per se. Mostly because of the logical consequences that that would imply.

I.e. Lascannon. Umm... I survived because my luckily placed hip-flask took the Lascannon shot for me o_O
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat
One thing I would say about the lascannon for example... There are degrees of being hit, so a hit in the area enough to make you duck, well 5 times out of 6 you are too close to the lascannon blast that things are going to go badly for you, but the other 1 in 6 might be you're hit... but only by the outter edge of its beam, causing a lovely smell of bacon and slightly charing/flash burning/tanning heavily so you look like you're from Essex down one side. This could be considered a 'hit' and would be enough to get you pinned, but not actually 'wounded'. Think I'm agreeing with others but trying to add that its not necessarily not hit, just you've been lucky to have only suffered a 'glancing blow'
 
So Necromunda's always been a bad analogue of real life fighting (but an awesome game). The fact that the guns don't seem to do as much damage as they ought (much to the consternation of newer players) is the result of having a game balanced on the Close Combat V Long Range distinction. Guns have been toned down in this universe, so that Goliath players won't die before they're half-way across the battlefield.

That said, it was when I was doing semi-regular write-ups and battle-reports that I found myself having issues with the way people are constantly hit, thrown to the floor, then get back with nary a scratch ... It felt awkward. For this reason, in the future, I have chosen to go with a "hit" meaning that gunfire has been aimed in their general direction and has come within at least a foot of actually hitting them (the attacker, shooting from distance, can't be sure). This motivates the target to keep their heads down and tuck their feet in tight (pinned). They can feel the wind as bullets pass their faces and shards of rock-crete are chipped from their cover, scratching their arms and cheeks.

Only a wounding-hit is significant enough for me to write it in narrative as a genuine hit ... with blood and stuff ... and the associated panic-related adrenal burst. The dude/dudette has been injured and only the close attention of his/her buddies or a sawbones can save them now. The lethality of the hit is still defined by the SI-Table, as though it could be any other way.

... on a side note, I phukkin love this game ... We really need to finish BTiLD soon.
 
Agreed Beardy. IMO that's the only way to make logical sense of it in my head.

On the other hand - not sure if you read the gigantic Flamers/Overwatch thread but I'd argue that the balancing of shooting vs. cc has a way to go yet, as your Goliaths (and Escher, dammit!) definitely do get shot to shit on their way across the board ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat and spafe
@BeardLegend: I remember some stats quoted in the old Cyberpunk 2020 RPG, apparently taken from the FBI. Apparently in RL gangland-style firefights, something like one bullet in 32 actually hits someone. Seems to me like Necro doesn't get the resulting shots fired/enemy downed ratio too far off - the way the rules are balanced gangers are just much more likely to 'score a hit' and said 'hit' is much less likely to actually do something. Either way I really like your fluff for it here - makes every bit of sense!
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat
@Doghead13 - I agree with you (or at least, potentially, with the FBI) ... but in gangland shootouts, they're exactly that ... shootouts. You don't have CC specialists in real life, armed with swords or chains, mooching their way forwards, taking cover behind crates so that they can charge their enemy and bash his skull in. There's no glory in the street (Hive ... whatever). Close Combat in real life (outside of disciplined combat) is for when things go badly and desperately wrong. In Necromunda that's the point. Win the charge, Maul Opponent.

This is why I say it's a bad analogue of real life fighting. No-one (unless they're a genuine fruit loop) really wants to be machete deep in someone else's guts. Better to hang back and loose a few above my target so my mates think i'm helping. This is the psychology of street warfare ... and until recently, (like, the last 60 or 70 years) warfare in general.

@ineptmule - as with Cawdor ... look at our injury lists compared to Delaque/Van Saar. Close combat is almost incidental ... it's what happens when the shootout isn't decisive. Actually, the more I think about it ... the more I think Necro might have it right. I needs to meditate on this one. :p

Yeah I read quite a lot of the thread before giving up when I realised my reply post would take too long to write. Basically - Hand flamers got it wrong imo. I like the rest of the chat. Overwatch needs toned back if we want to balance the game (I think that we should be able to choose who runs the overwatch fire, rather than the shooter picking who he can shoot at)... I remain uncertain that we need any more than that (traditionalist). We saw a lot of close combat in BTiLD and no CC gang should have a cake walk getting to @Alobar's Van Saar.
 
  • Like
Reactions: trollmeat and spafe
@Doghead13 One other thing that is abstracted that will play havoc with those numbers is that one dice roll doesn't always mean one bullet... In the case of a missile it prob does, but a juve with an autopistol may well have let loose with half a clip and still represented by a single dice roll...
 
"hit" meaning that gunfire has been aimed in their general direction and has come within at least a foot of actually hitting them

*nods* Nicely done.


Also, I was under the impression that the only real way to get into close combat was to throw Superior Numbers and don't care if half your cheap scavvy scum die in the process :p