N18 How are you discussing gangs & loadouts?

How much do you care at optimization/power when discussing gangs & loadouts?

  • Optimization is most important

    Votes: 3 7.1%
  • Optimization is medium imortant

    Votes: 28 66.7%
  • Fluff or die!

    Votes: 11 26.2%
  • Don't know

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .
Depents how many characters you want to include.
Is Splinter the leader? Then he should not be effected by rats (Cawdor-Skill).
Leonardo? Make him a Dealque Nacht-Ghoul with sword(s). They are all Ninjas at least...
Raphael needs more ferocity like berserkcharge. But maybe as a semi-leader make him your Champ with group activation 1?
Donatello should have something like a mechanic-skill. Maybe like the Orlock-hired gun.
Michelangelo will be a bit weak as I don't see many good weapons for him but a club. Nunchucks: cool, but useless! XD
Give every Turtle WS3+, BS4+ (throwing knives, I think Raphael could get BS3+) and T4 with a 4+ Save (additional 6++ for good reflexes?).
April can be an Escher with the propagandist-skill.
Casey as some hive scumm. But give him an Orlock Jet Pack to profit from Donatello. :D

I would not see a Gang like this as a Players Gang but as a tool for the arbitrator. So go wild on the rules and have a fun time. ^^
Thanks, That looks like a fun gang! Toying around with a CGC gang too, since I could bring Leo as the leader to group activate everyone. The younger brothers are champions, will hire splinter as a hired gun from time to time to kill some big characters, and 4 initiates to work the territories.
 
I think this is a really good question. It goes back to my pet peave which is people just looking at cost/stat ratios really mechanistically and saying "just get a plasma pistol instead" to everything. I think what I like to do for newbies is just save them from going down rabbit holes by advising they play something that doesn't require too much mental load (heaps of different weapons/skills and psyionics), and by steering them clear of obvious mistakes that will ruin the fun.
 
I typically prefer variety over pure optimization where skills, special weapons and heavy weapons are concerned, even with my proclivities towards playing Van Saar. As it is, I've seen too many "optimized" net lists that more or less amount to "my toolbox is just a set of identical hammers" for no other reason than because of sheer arbitrage, which insofar as I've seen on the tabletop only results in gangs that aren't fun to play with or against for the average player (and barely one step ahead of the unfortunate position of only being able to field what little you own just to play a game).

Thanks, but no thanks - I may entertain a focused list that presents a range of complementary weapon/skill combinations that are each super-effective in their own right (wider range of tools in the toolbox to play with, after all), but fast shot/gunslinger plasma spam is D.O.A. as far as I'm concerned. If there is to be any "spam" that I can really tolerate, it's pretty much limited to basic gangers and juves since you need them on a nearly one-for-one basis if you want more of the fun toys anyway.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MusingWarboss
worn out rifle on a stick , bam! the empraah takes care of the rest
 
If someone is showing up here on the forums asking about gang builds, they're generally not asking about what is cool or narrative, as those things are pretty subjective. If they're asking for build advice, it's generally two questions: Is this legal? Is this effective?
Most of the time when people on the forums give list advice, if they give a min/max or high competitive suggestion, they include a caveat identifying it as such.