Moving up and down ladders

Jembo17

Gang Champion
Apr 27, 2013
383
342
98
Derbyshire, UK
A debate occurred last night in the below situation.

The model above is a H-t-H specialist and positioned himself right at the top of the ladder.

The two models below wanted to move up the ladder and then promptly shoot him at point blank range.

The bone of contention was that if they moved up the ladder then wouldn't they have to engage the guy in hand-to-hand as you can't move through another model?
As regards them going up the ladder on one side of the bulkhead and then appearing on the other side of it (hope that description makes sense) we play that if you go up a ladder then you have to stay on the same side unless there is no alternative.

IMG_0609.JPG
 
his base looks to be over the hole in the ground. thus he would prevent you from climbing up the ladder, but you can also shoot him from where he is standing. atleast thats how i would rule it
 
hmm, an awkward one. I wouldn't say you can shoot him from where you are... but I'd possibly be of the mind that you can go to the far side of that bulkhead and climb up there, course you might not have enough movement to get clear of it to shoot him after, but that's what clever placement of cc specialists gives you, control of the other gangs movement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jembo17
On my terrain (original), I have the ladders of the bulkheads switched to the outside of the building. That makes it a bit more logical in my opinion, as you can only move up on that side.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alobar and spafe
On my terrain (original), I have the ladders of the bulkheads switched to the outside of the building. That makes it a bit more logical in my opinion, as you can only move up on that side.

I do exactly the same, as it seems to make the most sense and not all the floors have an opening that lines up.
 
hmm, an awkward one. I wouldn't say you can shoot him from where you are... but I'd possibly be of the mind that you can go to the far side of that bulkhead and climb up there, course you might not have enough movement to get clear of it to shoot him after, but that's what clever placement of cc specialists gives you, control of the other gangs movement.

I'd say that shooting gangs have a general advantage over close combat ones, which is why I was of the same opinion as you @spafe
On the infrequent occasions in which it arises, I find it amusing when ranged gangers have to "cheese it!" from a CC specialist due to tactical positioning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: .juno and spafe
Yeah, that's my thought, and its always comfortably re-affirming to see those beardy gits fleeing from good honest goliath muscle :p
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jembo17
Pfft! I'm ashamed of you @BeardLegend ! good honest emp fearing Cawdor afraid to charge a mewling unbeliever! @Alobar on the otherhand I expect nothing less from your skulking bearded techno cowards! :p

[All in jest of course, melta the b****]
 
Well tooty frooty is a very special case. The time that I have charged against the odds have rarely worked out for me. When I charged with my leader against nathanie1's leader I got my ass handed to me and lost the scenario in one foul swoop. The next game against ineptmule could have gone the same way, but I did charge with my leader and my dog if I recall correctly? I still lost the game but that's necro for ya...! I admit other than my leader and 2 others, my entire van Saar gang are a bunch of cowards. I have no shame. I will not be playing van Saar again I. A hurry...
 
  • Like
Reactions: spafe and .juno
How do other people play finishing your movement on a ladder?

LAGGNOG play it as the model is however many inches up (or down) the ladder as they can be, i.e. If the model had already moved 6" to get to the base of a ladder they would then be 2" up. We make a mental note and that model is free to be shot. The next turn they move from that point. A bit messy but it's works.

Also if we are playing the above then we should also allow models to voluntary stop their movement at any point on a ladder.
 
I've done both "you must finish your move on terra firma" and the "halfway up the ladder" thing. Both have their obvious advantages and disadvantages. For the latter we placed the model at the top/bottom of the ladder (depending on if the fighter was climbing up or down), and then placed a dice next to it showing the number of inches the model had climbed. During shooting phases we had to hold the models in place to determine LOS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spafe and Jaws
The rule for charging has at the end:

Note that you cannot move models into hand-to-hand combat except by charging – any move intended to bring a fighter into hand-to-hand combat is a charge by definition.
​
Playing as many people are suggesting here would change "intended to" into "which does" in that sentence. Otherwise the loophole is "I did not intend to charge him". I would say it is fair for the Van Saar to attack in that photo, the CC guy cannot block the ladder access. but the Van Saar has to charge . . . or take a more difficult shot . . . or make a 'tactical withdrawal'
 
  • Like
Reactions: .juno and trollmeat