So, Squats!
As someone who goes on about encouraging the production of Space Dwarves I thought I'd better put some of my money where my mouth is, and ordered a pack of five Brokkr from Mantic, along with the makings of a zombie horde because holy cow are Mantic's zoms cheap.
Straight out of the box impression of the Brokkr and they're ever so slightly, well, flashtastic. Don't get me wrong, these are really nice sculpts, but there was a lot of flash and strong mould lines all over them - though not nearly as much as you find all over Finecast and I haven't seen any bubble-type casting flaws on them. I'm also not a fan of Mantic's decision to make them monopose - most of the arms are separate, only two cast in through the entire pack, but they've got these weird angular plug and socket thingies moulded onto them that establish what arm goes with who - not the greatest design decision if you ask me. C'mon Mantic, how about a multipose set of these guys? That'd be rather lovely if you ask me.
There were also a couple of slightly warped weapons. The leader guy's hammer's handle and the 'magma rifle' were both bent, and being plastic straightening them without any snapping going on was ever so slightly interesting.
As for Mantic's bases, they seem kinda like reinventing the wheel tbh. They work just fine, but I've never been a fan of any sort of cast-in base and the Brokkr have small circular examples attached to their feet, that drop down into the matching indent in the base proper. I note that Mantic's Plague Zombie sprues don't have this 'feature' though the fantasy zoms do, and I suspect that a mashup of parts from Mantic zombies and GW's Flagellants and Chaos Cultists may very well make some really nice scavvies.
Size-wise the Brokkr are visibly taller and a bit thinner than a plastic Squat or a GW dwarf, though even the tallest and most upright member of the five only just comes up to Fred the Scalecadian's shoulder pad (apart from his spiked-up hair, that is) and a couple of them are in very hunched-up postures, making them look much shorter than they are.
Here's a scale comparison pic and a photo of the line-up of five Brokkr. The guy in the middle in the second photo is the one I used for the scale comparison photo.
and lastly an arm length comparison of plastic Squat and Brokkr; like the Brokkr themselves, the Brokkr arms are marginally longer than the GW Squat arms. I haven't got any GW plastic dwarf arms available; I may have to get some and compare them length-wise to this (carefully conserved) Squat arm sprue at some point.
Height-wise they're about halfway between GW squats/dwarves and humans, and tbh I wouldn't argue against their being used for either; they'd make just as good a short member of a human gang (I could see the leader guy as a shortarsed Van Saar) as they would a tall member of a squat gang.
In conclusion, I may very well get more of these lads as conversion fodder: may very well is going to become definite if Mantic see fit to make a multipose set in the style of these guys, I'd buy that like a shot.