I can't recall which was my first ever attempt at painting a miniature... But I do recall one of my first ever set painted. It was summer of 90. I was 15 and had badly broken my left leg late may, and stayed more than 50 days with a cast. After boring myself to death with WC 90 in Italia (one of the worst ever, I reckon) I painted my "Encounter at Khazad-Dûm" Citadel box in July, on a large wooden table outside my parents house in the countryside.
My technique was pretty basic. A base coat, a more or less mastered wash and some dry brushing highlighting. Unfortunately, I decided a few years ago to do justice to this great set with a new paint and stripped my Gandalf, Boromir and Aragorn characters. Only the Balrog remains with its original paint, but dissassembled.
I had anotehr great Citadel box : the Dwarf Lords of Legends. It was already quite old when I got it around 1989/1990.
I don't remember if I painted them before or after the Balrog set...? Anyway, it was around the same period. At that time, I mainly played RPG with High School friends, and was interested in miniatures mainly for collecting and painting. Such a game as WFB was unaffordable to my parents.
My favorite was Kimril the Giantslayer, since he was a badass looking dwarf and since he was on the cover of Warhammer RPG which I was playing at that time.
Borax Bloodaxe
King Gorrin
Throbin Death Eye
The Baron
For some reasons, three of them were never painted.
We can see that I was using a pretty thin black undercoat, more like a heavy wash, then painted them color by color, "as you dress" as I learnt back then.
Great thread, and great memories....
