N18 Why are people so concerned with effective/efficient gang loadouts?

errant82

New Member
Sep 21, 2017
2
19
3
Gloucester, UK
Necromunda was never meant to be a competitive game. It was always about rule of cool and telling a story on the tabletop. It saddens me that so many players seem to have missed that part these days and try and make spammy, ultra-efficient gangs.

I play for narrative and feel that's what Necromunda is designed for. It's not a balanced enough game to play competitively.

Thoughts?
 
Yes rule of cool should come first always but there's nothing wrong with making your gang efficient - nobody enjoys getting their backsides handed to them all campaign, with their lovingly painted models ending up crippled or dead; regardless of whether it's narrative or not. There needs to be a balance IMO, yes any WAAC players who abuse every loophole and overpowered unit/weapon to win will quickly find themselves without any players to face, but with the campaign RPG element it's natural for players to want to win and build their gangs accordingly. Nothing to say your gang can't look awesome, have loads of cool wargear and still do well on the battlefield :)
 
I have asked myself the same question countless times. Particularly every time I see someone asking about their new gang.

I don't care for a second what others think of my starting gang. It is super easy to create a starting gang. Take the minis you have that you think are coolest and start with that. As Metallica says, nothing else matters.
 
A multiplayer game that is not strictly cooperative is a competitive game.
As soon as you have at least two players, a ruleset and some kind of incentive to win the game, then those players are gonna try to win the game within the boundaries of this ruleset. If they are not doing that then they are not playing a game, they are taking part in a shared narrative experience.

If spamming <best weapon> and <best profile> is the best strategy, then it's natural for players to gravitate towards it. It's the designers' job to make sure that such a boring strategy is not an optimal one (let alone the best one) and to reward more interesting and varied gameplay. If they fail at that fundamental task, then you are left with only 3 choices:
  1. accept these few optimal strategies are the only viable ones
  2. do the designers' job and house-rule the game so that more options become viable (and I mean you actually have to write those rules, don't rely on some vaguely defined notion of 'cool', 'fun' or 'fairness')
  3. stop playing the game
You have to understand that all players exist on some kind of casual<->competitive sliding scale and that no approach is inherently better than the other. What you call rule-of-cool I call self-imposed limitation, and what you call WAAC I call clever play and list optimisation. A good game is a game where all the best lists are also the coolest ones.
 
It does seem to be the way to play these days. I was always a narrative player, creating stories and background for my gangs. Equipment was generally based on the original metal models of course, with a few conversions here and there, even for competitive events back in the day. Even back then there were players who were WAAC, and I have some horror stories of my own from those times.

The newest iteration of Necromunda has introduced an entirely new player base and it seems WAAC is the default for many (but certainly not all) of the young bloods. I can understand why though - these guys and girls have been raised on multiplayer online games where pasting your opponent is the way to win, either by paying IRL money to get better equipment or by honing your load out to the nth degree of efficiency. If you don’t win, you can’t really be having fun, right?

N18/19/20 plays into their hands by having obviously excellent/obviously junk items for similar costs and stacking extra potent rules upon rules for people who can afford to pay for more and more books - tabletop pay-to-win in effect. This is a design issue /choice that has been made by GW.

TLDR: NCE beckons you. Join us. Join usssssss...
 
Last edited:
There's always going to be WAAC gamers, even in games that really aren't suited for them. I remember encountering some in Mordheim, which was terribly balanced but insanely fun as a narrative game. For instance, skaven lists with nothing but the ridiculously under-priced slings. As long as there's some competitive element, some people will play it with the WAAC mentality.

Also, I think often players are coming from games that have a more competitive approach, like mainstream 40k (at least it was when I played, which is why I stopped playing), and so they might be used to that approach and adopting a more narrative style doesn't necessarily come easy.

I find the best solution is to try to find a group that embraces the narrative and rule-of-cool approach, but I know that's not always easy.
 
Like others have said, players exist on a spectrum and whereas utterly destroying your opponent isn't the goal for most people, conversely nobody likes sucking.

Newcromunda also isn't as role-playing friendly as the old edition, and the nature of house lists and predictable trade posts means there is a "meta" which people generally transition too.

Not all gangs suit role play either, and a fluffy, role play friendly Escher gang, for example will get steamroller by a Corpse Grinder gang simply because the latter has no "fluffy" mode..
 
Sadly, even if you yourself don't have the most competitive mindset, it may be easy to get dragged into it if several regular opponents think differently. If some bits of wargear or upgrades are simply so much more efficient than others and the people you're playing with go all-in on those, you may find yourself consistently blasted off the table unable to get much game in yourself, which equally quickly ruins your fun in all likelihood. So you appear to be left with the options of joining in, or just exiting. (Alternatively, find more like-minded opponents or convert existing ones to your point of view, but those are more difficult.)

I like knowing what's considered particularly good - so that I know what to avoid. Currently building a Mordheim Skaven warband with zero slings. Once went to an X-Wing tournament taking some ships that were considered absolute garbage, but tailored that list further to do okay against what was considered the meta. Self-imposed limitation? Absolutely. But in my view much more fun, interesting and rewarding than doing the thing everyone does because it's supposedly objectively the best. Besides, you can always blame any loss on your subpar list, while any victory is surely proof of your incredible genius? Seriously though, I enjoy two types of games: close matches in competitive games, or narrative, cinematic games in other games. As others said, Necromunda is far too poorly balanced to do well as a competitive game, so I don't see the point in playing it as such. Besides which, I always prefer the second category of game anyway. But, as Thorgor rightly pointed out, there simply is no universal definition of what people consider fun.
 
I also think the blame has to lie with the game designers for anything in the game that's considered overpowered, not with the players using that in their gangs. Let's look at the current top tier gangs for example: Van Saar & Corpse Grinders. Guys in sleek futuristic bodygloves with high tech plasma weaponry raining death on their enemies from afar - or hulking cannibals with motorised meat carvers charging in to turn foes into bloodmist. How do these two concepts not fit in with the narrative? Why is it wrong to model these 2 gangs in this way? They are both narratively very interesting and 'cool' gangs in the game.

The 'rule of cool' does not dictate you have to model and equip all your gangers with rubbish gear to appease some kind of anti-meta, that's ridiculous. And yes it will often not be a fun experience for anyone else facing these 2 gangs (even if they are not particularly optimised) however that's not the player's fault, it's the game designers. They could make just a couple of easy changes to bring these 2 gangs back into balance - my suggestion being BS3+ for VS leaders & champs and make the Butcher/Cutter masks only affect charging not shooting for CGC. Similar changes could be made for overpowered and undercosted gear. Unfortunately Necromunda won't receive the updates and errata that games like 40k receive because the playerbase isn't nearly as big.

Ultimately, there are no tournaments for Necromunda so objectively campaigns are going to have a narrative focus but that doesn't mean they shouldn't be competitive to a degree. Competitive & narrative can coexist, just need to find the balance.
 
I feel its a victim of hedged bets a little by the game creators.. crazy weird weapons, strange, cool, albeit useless skills for the narrative players... power creep, deep complex rules, and optimal loadouts for the competitive players... Something for everyone. Whilst i try always aim for the rule of cool campaign, my limited experience thus far has shown me that if we have a few players (or even 1) that slides towards the competitive side of that scale @Thorgor mentions above then the campaign can turn that way pretty quickly as the other players suddenly follow suit to keep up. Our playgroup are mainly players in their 30's with families. Getting out for a night to game is a treat that we all look forward to so no-one really feels good if they get kirb stomped. If it happens a few times its a safe bet they will be looking to spend that limited social time elsewhere. Next campaign im going to try run a side, linked narrative, co-op venator rpg. I feel this may help to inject back a bit of the rule of cool and more uniform enjoyment.
 
The campaign system itself lends itself to competitive play. The point of campaigns now is to win and get awards. As opposed to a framework to link your games like previous editions.

The way territory is won and how common going into recovery is means that if you lose a few early games your stuck at the bottom and those who win these games stay on top. Thereby encouraging player's to seriously think about the meta for their starting gang. As the first 2 games will can easily define your whole campaign. Even if you got destroyed in first few games in oldmunda the underdog and giant killer bonus meant you could build yourself back up.

Going on from the above point. A crew limit of 10 in most scenarios can also make it a bit harder to bounce back. With gangs having smaller numbers and a more concentrated strength. Trying to play a mission with a small crew to even the odds is less effective. As the stronger gang will be leaving less of his gang strength at home.

Progress for gangs and gangers is now done by shopping for optimised bling. With less XP gained that is also spent in optimised ways. With a few advances and weapons/equipment being seen as obvious winners. Give me the more random sub optimal advances and trading post of yesteryear anyday.

I think all these things naturally push people into a more competitive state of play. Even without taking into consideration that when building your gang some builds are going to have vastly different power levels.

For all of specialist games talk of creating a narrative game that's not competitive. They sure as hell have built a system that feels designed to push us into competitive gaming.

In short play NCE.

Oh and tactic cards as well. No point in many while having a solid number of no brainers.
 
It's a very delicate balance.

Firstly, effective generally is cool.
A fighter that does nothing but throws wet noodles around before being killed is lame, in spite of how cool noodles might theoretically be.

Secondly, the consequences of being uncompetitive in Necromunda can be dire. If you start to fall behind, your gang will just get slapped again and again. You will fall so far behind that you simply can't compete. And that's really not fun.

It's a line that I admit I've gotten wrong in every campaign I've played, and I've always ended up top-cat with my Escher. I don't build my gang to be the best I can. I build it to be good enough with weapons and loadouts I like and find fun.
 
Being able to plan your advancement and the timed campaign both point towards the intent for the new version being a tournament/event game. Whether or not they succeeded in that is questionable but it was clearly the intent. Some people really enjoy figuring out a meta list and as @Stoof mentioned, such attitudes exist in online games (I've lost count of the number of times I've been yelled at by teammates for using "sub optimal" units in strategy games) and RPGs (we all know that player with access to too many splat books).
nobody enjoys getting their backsides handed to them all campaign, with their lovingly painted models ending up crippled or dead
Firstly, effective generally is cool.
Secondly, the consequences of being uncompetitive in Necromunda can be dire. If you start to fall behind, your gang will just get slapped again and again. You will fall so far behind that you simply can't compete. And that's really not fun.
Have to disagree with these. There is however a big difference between being beaten by a superior opponent or bad luck and being beaten by poor game design. A well designed game will have the potential to make a comeback or see the previously unstoppable player fall. The lack of mechanics for this in N17/18/20 House of ??? Edition is fundamentally linked to the idea that a 'campaign' only lasts 6 games/weeks. A constantly shifting meta that is objectively superior means you have to buy the new hotness to compete and that is what they want.
 
For me, as someone who has literally just gotten into the game (bought my first gang yesterday!), I think there's a feeling of apprehensiveness. I don't want to build my gang "wrong" and have to buy more models for WYSIWYG. I'm also unsure of what a general loadout looks like or if there are certain options that'll lessen my enjoyment of the game.

For example, I just got a box of Eschers. The chem thrower looks awesome but in game is...meh? Do I build it because it's cool or leave it in favour of another option that in-game might be more enjoyable?

It helps me to see what other players generally take/avoid, why and let's me deviate from there.

For the record: Cool models/fluff > Fun gameplay > WAAC
 
For example, I just got a box of Eschers. The chem thrower looks awesome but in game is...meh? Do I build it because it's cool or leave it in favour of another option that in-game might be more enjoyable?

My advice to every new player is to start a gang by building only what you need, to begin with. Chances are that you won't fit more than 8 models into 1000 credits for a starting gang, and the remaining figures can be built when needed or with the benefit of having a couple of games to see what you enjoy.

In your specific example of the chem-thrower, it depends on a few factors:
  • Do you intend to get/use House of Blades makes?
If so, the design your own ammo rules will probably give it a significant boost but we can't say for certain until details are known.
  • Will you be using 3D terrain or the hardboard tiles from the 2017 boxed set?
The short ranges and limited approaches involved with the tiles makes the chem-thrower more useful.
  • Are you willing to repaint a model?
The chem-thrower makes a perfectly acceptable flamer with a different paint job, which is only slightly more expensive and very useful facing Corpse Grinders or other gangs going heavy on close combat.

If your answers to the above are all "no" then I would advise you to leave the chem-thrower for now. It's a high cost weapon that might not get much use, which is disheartening. See how dense your usual terrain is and what your opponents bring. A champion can always be given one later on and unless you ramp up your gang size quickly, you'll probably have enough parts to make the model then.
 
This isn't about WAAC, this is about large numbers of what do you think about this load out posts followed by advice based on efficiency, both here and on FB. The main problem is as I think Thorgor pointed out that these rules aren't balanced esp. weapon costs and there are definitely more efficient loadouts. The game may be narrative but the ruleset doesn't really encourage that. By having clearly better choices mixed with poor or almost nonexistent underdog mechanism, it does channel people towards optimum choices out the gate. Optimal is not WAAC, but it's not necessarily narrative either, though can be, and as such any distinctions are much more blurred.

Secondly, (and minor compared to above point) as a community we do tend to respond with optimal responses, though here more than FB you do see an occasional 'go on try a chem thrower for fun/variety'. Personally as Escher I do run 2-3 lasgun girls but often throw a mix of Shotgun, Autogun and Needlers for variety of nothing else. Plus possibly that's just how I built the models..
Maybe we should work to offer more suggestions based on narrative/variety otherwise it's a little unfair to offer an optimal loadout on one hand and scream you must play fluffy/narrative on the other. (Not that they are necessarily mutually exclusive.)

I'm hoping the book of series will help in this regard by offering far more choice, that there will be more good choices even if they don't fix 'bad' as in heavy flamer options...

Finally the 'play narrative as it's not balanced' argument doesn't make sense. They are two separate issues a) play narratively / rule of cool because it's well cool & fun, why can't people have a narrative that's also efficient. b) the inbuilt unbalanced nature of the game needs both addressing and actually encourages optimal builds not narrative ones anyway..esp. as lack of underdog means people are fighting harder not to get curb stomped early on.
 
I think part of the reason why feedback tends to focus on efficiency rather than coolness is because I can comment objectively on the efficiency/effectiveness of a loadout. I can't tell you whether it's cool or not.
I think that's fair and I do it myself too. Though I think you can offer an opinion on what's cool to you, subjective as it may be. And it's why the main culprit is the ruleset, and subsequent lack of underdog mechanism.

For example, personally I prefer 3 different skills for leaders and champs as the skill reflects the personality. Despite my gut feeling that spring up is pretty much the best Escher skill. Likewise, fast shot is both effective and narratively cool, but adding a 2nd fast shooting champ detracts rather than adds to the cool factor imo.

I've got no absolute fixes here. I'd also add in my experience pushing narrative over competitive is easier in smaller 2-4 player groups than in bigger 10+ store based campaign groups. Not to have a go at people in either. Just smaller groups are easier to build consensus than larger less intimate groups, imo having been involved in both prior to lockdown. Just an awareness of impact of different gaming settings having different strengths/issues.
 
Their drive for more “content” in the game has actually led to more optimal builds than before. Ironically if you’ve got 100+ weapons to choose from you’re going to find ones that are reliable and not stupid expensive and you’ll pick the top 3-5 to use. Rarely will you pick number 100 which is expensive and ineffective.
Not unless there’s an incentive to do. Even in fluffy lists.

But much as Thorgor writes above, when you have a game which is ostensibly player vs player then competition creeps in. If it was Players vs Arbitrator (GM) controlled NPCs or enemies then it may be different.

Even for the full-fluff players I bet they’ve never done a Gang Fight and kept most members hidden and sent out a messenger Juve to try and call a truce or alliance with the opposition gang leader.
It kinda goes against the scenario but why not? Team up against another bigger foe instead, both grab loot and leg it?? That’s a valid part of narrative. Not just shooting the s*** out of each other every game.

Competitive players may not grasp that whole, feck the scenario, let’s RPG it. Who wins the scenario in this case? Dunno. How do you “win” a story? You’re both not dead and be have more loot. Sounds ok to me.
Especially if you can both go in against those damn CGC later as an alliance.